Rising Healthcare Costs Put a New Spotlight on Supplemental Benefits

By BeneRe
November 17, 2026

For employers and employees, the cost of healthcare isn't simply rising, it's accelerating.

A Marsh (formerly Mercer) study indicates that total health benefit costs per employee will increase an average of 8.2% in 2027, the largest increase since 2003, even after employers make planned changes to help control costs. Without those measures, employers estimate costs would rise an average of 11%. A recent PwC survey offers a similarly challenging outlook, projecting a 9% medical cost trend in 2027, the highest in 17 years. 

Employees are feeling the pressure, too. According to Aon (a leading global professional services and insurance brokerage firm) average employee out-of-pocket healthcare costs are expected to reach $2,167 in 2026, up 10% from the prior year. Higher deductibles, copays and other expenses are putting more financial responsibility on employees at the same time employers are struggling to control their own costs.

Behind these numbers are employers trying to manage increasingly expensive benefits programs and employees facing greater financial exposure when illness, injury or hospitalization occurs. Understanding what's driving these increases is an important first step toward addressing them.

What’s driving higher healthcare costs?

There's no simple, single explanation for rising healthcare costs. Instead, a combination of economic, industry and market factors continues to put pressure on the healthcare system.

And the challenge extends well beyond a single year. According to Business Group on Health, employer healthcare costs could increase a cumulative 76% between 2018 and 2027. The organization's research also projects a median 9.2% increase in employer healthcare costs for 2027 before plan changes. Together, these figures underscore a longer-term affordability challenge rather than a single difficult renewal year.

Research from Mercer and PwC points to several factors contributing to continued cost increases:

  • Higher hospital and provider costs. Inflation, rising operating expenses and consolidation among healthcare providers are contributing to higher prices for medical services.
  • Advances in medical treatment. New technologies, diagnostics and therapies are improving patient care and outcomes, but many come with higher costs.
  • Growing demand for healthcare services. Increased utilization, including behavioral health services, continues to place pressure on healthcare spending.
  • Changes in billing and reimbursement. New technologies and evolving reimbursement practices are contributing to higher claims costs and additional financial pressure across the system.

These pressures ultimately affect more than healthcare providers and insurance companies. As KFF points out, rising healthcare spending can lead to higher costs for employers, increased employee contributions and greater financial strain on households.

As costs continue to climb, employers are becoming more willing to question longstanding benefits arrangements. As reported in a September 2, 2026, New York Times article, employers are seeking greater visibility into healthcare spending, taking a closer look at relationships with insurers, pharmacy benefit managers, providers and consultants, and considering alternatives that might deliver better value.

That willingness to challenge traditional approaches deserves a place in the supplemental benefits conversation, too.

Why supplemental benefits matter more now

As employers look for ways to manage rising healthcare costs, employees are often being asked to shoulder a greater share of the expense. In fact, a Mercer survey indicates that 48% of large employers expect to make medical plan changes that increase employee out-of-pocket costs. Additional research from Marsh indicates that 59% of employers plan cost-cutting changes to health benefits in 2027.

This growing financial challenge is helping to make supplemental benefits an increasingly important part of the benefits conversation.

Accident, critical illness and hospital indemnity insurance are designed to complement major medical coverage, providing additional financial protection when employees need it most.

While supplemental benefits don't directly reduce the underlying cost of healthcare, they can help employees manage the financial impact of unexpected health events and expenses that major medical insurance may not fully address.

When employers respond to rising healthcare costs by increasing deductibles, adjusting cost-sharing or narrowing coverage, employees can face greater financial exposure. Supplemental benefits cannot eliminate those costs, but they can provide cash benefits when a covered accident, illness or hospitalization occurs, helping employees manage expenses during an already difficult time.

But as these benefits become more important, the way they are structured, priced and managed matters more, too.

Are supplemental benefits delivering the value employees deserve?

Supplemental benefits exist for a reason. They provide an additional layer of financial protection that can make a meaningful difference when employees experience unexpected medical events.

At a time when employees are being asked to absorb more healthcare costs, it's worth examining how much value they're receiving from the premiums they already pay for supplemental coverage. Employers may have limited control over broader healthcare inflation, but they can take a closer look at how their supplemental benefits are priced, structured and managed.

The opportunity for employers isn't to step away from supplemental benefits. It's to take a closer look at whether those programs are delivering the value they should.

That means asking questions that go beyond enrollment and participation.

Where do employees' premium dollars go? How much is being returned through claims? How are brokers and advisors compensated? How does pricing compare with similar programs? Are potential conflicts transparent? And is the organization regularly reviewing and documenting those answers?

These questions are becoming increasingly relevant as industry analysis and litigation bring greater attention to the value, transparency and oversight of voluntary benefit programs.

Recent industry articles, including "ERISA Fiduciary Duties and Voluntary Benefits: New Litigation Trends" and "Voluntary Benefits Move into the ERISA Litigation Crosshairs", reinforce the importance of evaluating premiums, commissions, claims experience and the processes used to select and monitor voluntary benefit programs.

For employers, that can mean:

  • Documenting carrier selection and review processes
  • Benchmarking premiums, commissions and claims performance
  • Reviewing claims experience and loss ratios
  • Maintaining records of benefit program decisions
  • Ensuring compensation arrangements are transparent
  • Reviewing applicable ERISA fiduciary responsibilities

These practices aren't simply about responding to increased scrutiny. They can help employers better understand what they're purchasing and what their employees are receiving in return.

And when employees are facing greater financial pressure, making every premium dollar work harder becomes an increasingly important part of delivering meaningful benefits.

A better path forward

Rising healthcare costs make supplemental benefits more relevant, not less.

As employers reconsider longstanding healthcare arrangements and look for greater transparency and value, supplemental benefits deserve that same level of attention. After all, if employers are rethinking how they purchase and manage major medical coverage, shouldn't they apply that same scrutiny to supplemental benefits?

Employers have an opportunity to demand greater transparency, better understand program economics and take a more active role in evaluating whether their benefits are delivering meaningful value.

That's where BeneRe offers a different approach. BeneRe's voluntary benefits captive model was designed to bring greater transparency and alignment to accident, critical illness and hospital indemnity benefits. Employers gain greater visibility into premiums, claims, expenses and program performance, along with a structure designed to support ongoing oversight and return unused underwriting funds for the benefit of plan participants.

Because as healthcare costs continue to rise, supplemental benefits shouldn't simply add another line to an employee's benefits package. They should help make healthcare more financially manageable for the people those benefits were designed to protect.